Friday, December 30, 2011

Your GPS Watch May be Lying to You

Today on the New York Times website I came across an article about GPS watches and their inaccuracy in measuring distance and pace.  I was startled to read just how off these watches can be.  I always had an inkling my Garmin wasn't quite 100% accurate, but I had no idea how wrong it could be.


"It seems clear enough that a GPS watch is not very accurate, yet online runners’ forums, like one at the Web site of Runners World, are filled with comments from confused athletes who rely on the devices. One poster, for example, ran a half marathon and wore a GPS watch that said the distance was 12.8 miles instead of 13.1."

There have been many times during a run where I feel like I am really pushing it and working hard and I look down bemused to see a pace much slower than I imagined.  A few reports mentioned in this article stated that paces can sometimes be off by as much as a minute and a half!  This is when it becomes really important to listen to our bodies -- the most accurate device out there. 

This is, of course, frustrating news, especially thinking that I may run more than the intended 20 miles of a long run.  Who on earth wants to do that?  But this news also serves as an important reminder to keep it simple.  Many ultra-runners run for time not mileage. Rather than going out for a 15 mile run, they might go out for a 2 hour run.  It's a different concept but it brings us to the same goal.

When it comes to intervals or speedwork, pace is clearly important.  This is when it might be best to hit the track with a basic stopwatch.  For Christmas Angela bought me a pretty basic Timex Ironman watch for timing intervals, strides and repeats.   It's lightweight, easy to use and perfect for these types of workouts.

I will definitely continue to use my Garmin, I will just be less trusting of the numbers.  If I feel like I had a good run and the Garmin tells me otherwise, I'll trust my body.  Back to basics.



Do you rely on a GPS watch?

Does this news surprise you?

43 comments:

  1. I've seen a few of these articles lately. I'm not really surprised or bothered- 12.8 instead of 13.1? 0.3 off? I can live with that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I ran for years before I got my first Garmin. I depended on routes that I measured with my car's odometer. On trails I'd run by time and estimate mileage. When I got my first Garmin I found that it reported almost identical mileage to what I'd mapped out. I've created cross country courses using a wheel and had it match the gps almost identically. So I do depend on it to be fairly accurate, both for running and cycling. As for speed work on the track, a stopwatch is all you need. I do find phone apps to be much more inaccurate than the Garmin. I've used both at the same time and been amazed at how different they were.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Saw this article last week and I think it did a great job of pointing out what most gps runners already know but don't like to acknowledge. It's a trendy thing to run with technology these days, and pretty neat too. But it does fool us into ignoring and assessing how our bodies actually feel and using our head. In the past several months I've rarely ran with my garmin and instead just ran for enjoyment. While I think gps devices can be useful, they also tend to be annoying and can manage to suck all of the fun out of running.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't use a GPS watch b/c I can't afford one: FACT. lol but I did just get a nike + for my birthday. I think it's pretty accurate but I never trust the pace. I'm going to use it on a set known distance and race it and see what it says. I think a general idea of distance and pace is better than nothing. I used to have to map my runs and use a stop watch....which is probably just as inaccurate. As long as we're out there running I guess it's ok! :D

    ReplyDelete
  5. I "rely" on a GPS watch, but I also know its not going to be 100% accurate. It does give me a good idea of times and paces though. - I always just run by how I feel though and not by what my pace says.

    ReplyDelete
  6. i find that my instantaneous pace specifically is often grossly off, to the point that I really only rely on my splits and average pace. so clearly, this is a problem for speedwork! i admire the idea of simplicity, but i am too type A and need to know my stats! i think we all just need to take those numbers with the grain of salt, though. you're right though in that there is a big difference between ultra/trail running and road running. when doing the latter i am far more interested in paces, distance, etc, but not so much on the trails as there are so many other factors that effect the numbers. interesting article!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I do the same thing, I look down and my Garmin says a completely different number than I was thinking I was going! Good to know I am not alone, thanks for bringing this article up Kate!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Funny -- the two pictures you posted are exactly the two watches I own...

    I HOPE my Garmin is lying to me sometimes! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  9. I almost always train with a Garmin (but never on a track or in a race) but I'm well aware that it's not always accurate. Most of the time it's close enough, but a couple weeks ago I swear it must have synched up to an alien ship because my splits from an easy 4 mile loop I run all the time were 6:45, 5:19, 9:30 and 7:20 or something like that. Definitely good for a chuckle because I swear my pace never changed, it was probably around 7:30.

    ReplyDelete
  10. What?!?! What a bummer. I rely on my Garmin all the time. I tend to run better when I'm not too concerned about my pace anyway so I guess it's okay. I try not to look at my Garmin too much becuase it gives me anxiety.

    Happy new year, beautiful!!

    PS i miss you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I have a garmin 405 and a timex ironman too. I probably prefer my timex cause it's easier to use, but the garmin is more fun. I'm not surprised about the findings cause I've already noticed discrepancies. But it doesn't bother me. It's still fun to use :)

    Barbara
    My Running Shortz

    ReplyDelete
  12. Well mine seems to over estimate, one half marathon counted as 14.6 miles so something way off. I ended up doing the mile interval and calculating my pace myself. Now if only I could get someone to run behind me with a tape measure ;0

    ReplyDelete
  13. I mostly think it's funny that people swear by these things or that they are surprised by this! It's just a piece of technology...of course it can be flawed. Mine mostly has problems when it's in a city. The buildings interfere with the signal. When I'm running in the open, it has no problems. It matches up well with google maps / mapmyrun.

    Usually my races are a little long - 13.25 for my last 2 half's. I don't even think that means my Garmin is wrong. It just might mean that I didn't run the tangents!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'm not shocked to hear this. I have a Garmin 305 and sometimes the pace is all over the place. I live in a neighborhood with a lot of trees, so I usually blame it on that. I'm okay with my run being a few tenths of a mile shorter or longer than I think - that's close enough for me, and I like the freedom the Garmin gives to run where I want and still know (pretty much) how far I've gone.

    ReplyDelete
  15. In nutshell, weekly payday loans are a great option for sudden expenses to a salaried person. The instant nature of these cash options make them more beautiful and know more about our service please visit us our site http://instantdecisionloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/


    http://weeklypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://1monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://15minutepaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://instantdecisionloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  16. In a nutshell, 3 month loans are most convenient cash aid for you which not only help you to recover your financial injuries but also sustain your good credit record and know more about our serives please visit us our site 3 month loans UK.

    http://3monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://12monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://sundaypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weekendpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weeklypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://15minutepaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://1monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://instantdecisionloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://3monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://30dayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://24monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://50poundloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  17. In nutshell, weekly payday loans are a great option for sudden expenses to a salaried person. The instant nature of these cash options make them more beautiful and know more about our service please visit us our site 30 day payday loans.

    http://30dayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://12monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://sundaypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weekendpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weeklypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://15minutepaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://1monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://instantdecisionloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://3monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://3monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://24monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://50poundloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  18. In short, 3 month payday loans are a remedy for all monetary crisis or obstacles for a borrower. By availing such finances, one can easily resolve his major complications and take a step forward in his life.

    Vanessa Paradis teaches the people about how to avail loans and use them. To find 3 month payday loans, 3 month payday loans bad credit, 3 month loans. 90 day loans, payday loans, bad credit loans & no credit check loans UK. you need to visit-

    http://3monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://12monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://sundaypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weekendpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://weeklypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://15minutepaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://1monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://instantdecisionloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://3monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://30dayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://3monthpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
    http://24monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  19. No credit check loans helps the individual in availing the instant cash for the individual’s mid month fiscal crunch without going through any process of credit check. This is specially meant for the bad credit holders who have the fear of rejection of their applicant because of their bad credit status and know more about our services please visit our site @ no credit check loans uk.

    http://nocreditcheckloans.paydayuk1hr.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  20. poundstillpayday are the perfect option for the individual who are in need of fast fiscal assistance for getting through the situation of emergency anytime and anywhere they want it.

    cash till payday uk
    12 month loans no credit check no guarantor
    installment payday loans
    100 pound loan

    ReplyDelete
  21. 1 hour loans no employment verification is fast source of cash for urgency without any credit checks made by the lenders. You can have the cash in the same day. Repay the loan on your next payday or in a month.

    1 hour payday loans no credit check
    6 month installment loans for bad credit
    12 month installment loans
    24 Hour Payday Loans Bad Credit

    ReplyDelete
  22. 24 Hour Loans Bad Credit has been designed by the banks to help out the bad credit holders who are looking for availing the additional funds require to meet the cash shortage in order to fulfill their fiscal emergency.

    payday loans for 12 months
    24 7 Bad Credit Loans
    1 Year Loans UK
    12 month payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  23. In summary, 6 month payday loans can be a viable option for you if you follow the guidelines sincerely. Also, must repay on time to make positive changes to your credit score. For more information you need visit : Six Month Loans Payday

    long term loans no credit check
    next day pay advance
    Need Money before Payday
    auto loans bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi,

    Very Very good and usable post. Thank's to share your experience with us. I will try to remember these tips in my blog commenting task.

    The blog was absolutely fantastic! Lots of great information and inspiration, both of which we all need!b Keep 'em coming... you all do such a great job at such Concepts... can't tell you how much I, for one appreciate all you do!

    Thanks

    1 month loans for bad credit
    12 month loans for bad credit no guarantor
    business start up loans with poor credit
    2 month payday loans
    short term loans uk bad credit

    Simply awesome Really interesting ,,brilliant post..thanks for sharing...!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bad credit instant car loan are here to assist the people in their economic stability and to demolish their suddenly emerged financial obligations. This provides the individual a favorable facility to procure money that will consume less time.for more information you need to visit;Payday UK Loans

      6 month cash loans
      next day payday loans no credit check direct lender
      Loans for 6 Months
      bad credit instant car loan


      Delete
  25. In short, Fast Payday Loans are free from all idle formalities. These finances come with bunch of benefits which are only for the convenience of the customers.

    poor credit secured loan
    monthly payday loans
    24 month payday loans
    No Credit Check Loans
    Payday Loans for Bad Credit

    ReplyDelete
  26. sunday payday loans, door to door loans for unemployed, student loans for bad credit , 14 day payday loans, home collection loans for people on benefits


    sunday cash loans
    loans for unemployed people
    federal student loans for people with bad credit
    14 day payday loans no credit check
    small cash loans for people on benefits

    ReplyDelete
  27. Long term unsecured personal loans the individual in availing the instant cash with long repayment duration in spite of their being bad credit holder. Individual borrowing money in this does not have to worry about the quick repayment.


    long term unsecured loans
    short term loans bad credit no brokers
    loans for unemployed
    500 loans over 12 months

    ReplyDelete
  28. Payday loans no credit check UK is being crafted for the applicant whose credits cores are being affect by the bad credit factors such as bankruptcy, arrears, delays, insolvency, and many more. Individual in this can get the fund without going through any process of credit verification.


    payday loans no credit check direct lenders
    payday loans direct lenders
    12 month loans for bad credit no guarantor no brokers
    low interest payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  29. 2 month loans are having many advantages that are providing more and more benefits to the borrowers. By using these loans, many people are leading tension-free life in U.K and you need to visit, 2 month loans.

    60 day loans
    cash via text
    12 month online loans
    3 Month Cash Loans
    loans for people
    12 month loans no guarantor

    ReplyDelete


  30. Suppose you cannot arrange faxing and you have a bad credit profile. 3 month payday loans no faxing are available for instant and timely help.

    instant approval no credit check loans
    Cash before Payday
    6 Month Payday Loans UK
    bad credit loans uk
    1000 personal loans

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi,

    Thanks for sharing wonderful news with us. I'm sure many people come to like your blog and gain benefit from this information you have provided. I would love to apply these terms on refinancing. Hope to see more amazing blog on your site.

    Have a great day...!!!

    12 Month Loans UK
    12 Month Payday Loans No Credit Check
    bad credit 12 month loans
    1 Year Loans Bad Credit
    Short Term Payday Loans No Credit Check
    Long Term Bad Credit Loans
    12 Month Loan No Credit Check

    ReplyDelete
  32. In a nutshell, 200 pound loans are useful only for those borrowers who have the ability to pay them back on given period.

    short term loans for students uk
    quick 3 month payday loans
    fast payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  33. 100 day loans have been designed specifically for helping the people to attend their occasional and unpredicted expenses which they are unable to attend because of their low income without waiting for their next pay cheque. To know more about services please visit @ Best Payday Loans for Bad Credit, Payday Loans for Bad Credit Same Day

    12 month loans instant decision
    bad credit payday loans instant decision
    1000 loans over 12 months
    3 Month Loans Same Day

    ReplyDelete
  34. 12 Month loans are advance in which the borrower has to reimburse the sum borrowed within a week. This provides the individual a usable fiscal device to finance all their emergencies and you need to visit, 12 month loans.

    12 month loans fast
    instant 24 month loans
    90 day payday loans phone
    30 day payday loans online
    90 day payday loans for bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  35. 24 month loans are the deal which serves the people money in difficult period when they are out of finance and needs smooth deals.this will help in gratifying the mid tenure needs abundantly.

    12 Month Loans Bad Credit
    2 month cash loans
    loans over 3 months bad credit
    Fast 12 Month Loans
    Bad Credit Loans Instant Decision Unemployed

    ReplyDelete
  36. Sunday payday loans help the applicant to enjoy their holiday stress free and happily .Individual through this can easily arrange the funds for taking care of their sudden expenses even on Sunday and you need to visit, sunday payday loans direct lenders.

    cash loans collected weekly
    same day loans no credit check
    84 Month Car Loan, 12 Month Loans for People with Bad Credit
    loans over 3 months bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  37. In nutshell, 12 month cash advance are a timely cash resource for a needy person. These funds are meant to clear all obstacles from people’s life and to make them happy forever.

    12 month cash advance loans
    24 hr Cash Loan
    6 month loans low interest
    instant approval loans for people with bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  38. Home collected loans are easy to apply as individual who can access the internet can easily apply for it without leaving their home through their computer with just

    some clicks of the mouse. For more details visit @ home collected loans no

    credit checks


    80 pound loans
    90 day loans uk
    <a href="http://www.shorttermloansdirectlenders.co.uk/short-term-payday-loans.html>short term payday loans UK</a>

    ReplyDelete
  39. In brief, 500 pound loans are an easy and safe way to secure yourself against financial challenges. These funds are instant and help you when you are in dire need of cash. For more detail please visit @ 500 Pound Loans

    sunday payday loans
    long term loans for unemployed
    text loans in minutes

    ReplyDelete
  40. 12 months loans poor credit are especially launched to help the individual whose are facing problem in availing through funds because of their adverse credit ratings. Individual in order to avail the funds are not requiring going through any process of credit verification.

    instant bad credit 12 month loans
    small long term loans for bad credit
    last minute payday UK
    short term loans over 12 months

    ReplyDelete
  41. 1 Month Loans are friendly finance option for the working people who need quick and handy money in the mid of the month.

    1 months loans
    3 month payday loans no credit check
    3 month loans online
    12 month loans bad credit no brokers
    uk payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  42. Hi,

    Very Very good and usable post. Thank's to share your experience with us. I will try to remember these tips in my blog commenting task.

    The blog was absolutely fantastic! Lots of great information and inspiration, both of which we all need!b Keep 'em coming... you all do such a great job at such Concepts... can't tell you how much I, for one appreciate all you do!

    Thanks

    100 payday
    100 pound loan uk
    instant decision payday loan
    direct lender uk
    12 month payday loans uk

    ReplyDelete